Are Seamless Pipes Stronger Than Welded?

One of the frequent inquiries while selecting the most appropriate type of pipe for industrial, structural, or even routine applications is if seamless pipes are stronger than welded ones. Each type possesses its particular features, advantages, and restrictions that could slightly complicate the selection process. Through a thorough examination of the strength variances between seamless and welded pipes, this article will investigate the manufacturing of each, the factors affecting their durability, and the best uses for each. Ultimately, you will gain a clearer understanding of which option best fits your particular requirements and the rationale behind it.

Understanding Pipe Types

Seamless pipes have no welded seams and are produced by extruding a solid piece of metal into a hollow tube. This method provides very high durability, enabling seamless pipes to bear high pressures and temperatures. Therefore, these pipes are suitable for use in the oil, gas, and industrial systems where such conditions exist. Conversely, welded pipes are produced by rolling and joining steel plates together, resulting in an overlapped seam. They might not be as strong as seamless pipes in extreme conditions, but they are cheaper, and so they are more widely used in low-pressure applications. The decision between seamless and welded pipes depends on the specific requirements of the intended use, such as strength, pressure, and budget.

What are Seamless Pipes?

Seamless pipes are powerful, hollow tubes made without any welding, providing great resistance to both pressure and temperature. This makes them suitable for use in tough industrial and energy-related areas.

What are Welded Pipes?

Welded pipes are produced by rolling steel plates into a cylindrical shape and then joining the edges by welding, providing inexpensive options for transporting liquids and gases in applications with low to medium pressure.

Key Differences Between Seamless and Welded Pipes

Manufacturing Processes

Seamless tubes are made by a method called extrusion. First, a solid steel billet is heated to extreme temperatures, and then it is pierced with a mandrel to make a hollow tube. The tube is then drawn out and formed in various ways using rollers and dies to achieve the specific size and thickness. Seamless pipes, being without seams, give them greater strength and the ability to handle high temperature and pressure, which is the main cause of their continuous use in the oil and gas, power generation, and chemical processing industries. Global seamless pipe production reached around 30 million tons in 2022, according to the latest industry statistics, thus confirming their indispensable position in the sectors as mentioned above.

Welded Pipe Manufacturing Process

The production of welded pipes begins with the rolling of steel plates or strips into a tube-like shape, and the edges are then fused together using techniques such as Electric Resistance Welding (ERW) or Submerged Arc Welding (SAW). Post-welding, the pipes are subjected to additional treatments like annealing, straightening, and inspecting, to guarantee their quality and longevity. For larger diameters and moderate pressure applications, welded pipes are the best choice. Advances in manufacturing and processing have made welded pipes more cost-effective and thus more popular. Their global production in 2022 accounted for around 60% of the total steel pipes market, as per industry statistics, owing to their versatility for different applications.

Drawing a comparison between the manufacturing methods, it is clear that seamless pipes, with their consistent structure, are the most reliable for high-stress situations, while welded pipes can be considered a cost-saving option for large pipe sizes and low-stress conditions.

Seamless Pipe Manufacturing Process

The phase of construction for a seamlesspipe starts with a solid cylindrical steel billet. This solid piece of steel is subjected to extremely high temperatures, typically around 2,200°F (1,200°C), making it very soft and easy to work with. After that, the solid steel is pierced with a rod or a mandrel, turning it into a hollow tube. The tube is then passed through a series of mills that elongate it while simultaneously reducing the diameter and thickness of its walls to meet specific standards and dimensions. Consequently, the product is a pipe without any welded seams, making it more uniform and strong throughout.

The ability to produce pipes with remarkable strength and resistance to pressure is one of the main features of the seamlesspipe manufacturing process. In 2023, according to industrial statistics, seamless pipes are primarily used in high-performance applications such as oil and gas exploration, power generation, and chemical processing plants. Due to their resistance to pressure fluctuations, high temperatures, and corrosive environments, they are considered the best option for industries with high demands.

Strict quality control measures are part of the processes involved, including non-destructive testing, which guarantees the pipe's integrity. Reports from the market indicate that by 2030, the global seamless steel pipe market will achieve a CAGR of 5.3% starting from 2023, driven by demand in the energy sector and infrastructure projects. New technology, such as hot spinning and pilger mills, has already been extensively used to improve the efficiency of production and the quality of the product, and thus ensure that seamless pipes are meeting the demanding conditions of the modern industrial applications.

Welded Pipe Manufacturing Process

The process of creating a welded pipe mainly involves forming a steel plate or strip, followed by welding it into a cylindrical shape. The two major processes of welded pipe production are longitudinal seam welding and spiral seam welding. The former is often implemented for smaller diameter pipes, using precision welding along the length of the strip, while the latter is done for larger diameter pipes and includes the formation of the steel into a spiral shap,e which is then welded at the edges.

The recent industry reports have stated that the technological advancements such as high-frequency induction welding (HFIW) and submerged arc welding (SAW) have added efficiency and quality to the welded pipe manufacturing significantly. To illustrate, HFIW has gained a reputation for producing a continuous and uniform weld seam with very few defects, hence making it very favorable in high-pressure applications such as the oil and gas industry.

Furthermore, modern methods incorporate non-destructive testing techniques as part of the process, such as ultrasonic and radiographic inspections, to guarantee the weld seams' structural integrity. Data from leading industry players indicate that productivity in welded pipe mills has increased significantly, with some plants now able to produce over 1,000 metric tons of welded pipes per day. The automation and advanced monitoring systems widely used in the facilities significantly impact the efficiency of the weld pipe production process, ensuring high quality at a relatively low cost.

The innovations not only help but also guarantee that the pipes are able to cope with the strict requirements of the various industries like construction, energy, and water transportation, to mention a few.

Strength and Durability

Welded pipe, because of its strength and durability, is the most reliable among different kinds of pipes; thus, it has become a must in many industries. The welding process not only creates a strong joint but also makes the pipes capable of withstanding high pressures and extreme environmental conditions. Current statistics report that the tensile strength of new welded steel pipes could range from 400 to 700 MPa, depending on the specific grade and production process. On top of that, the corrosion resistance is made even better by the application of protective coatings which greatly increase the lifespan in environments like seawater, chemical exposure, and underground pipelines that are very inhospitable for pipes.

Welded pipes have benefited from cutting-edge technologies, such as high-frequency induction welding (HFIW), in terms of structural integrity and dependability. Reports reveal that the pipes made by HFIW possess better fatigue resistance quality compared to traditional welded pipes. Moreover, stringent testing methods like hydrostatic tests and radiographic inspections are in place to guarantee that no pipe goes out without having met the safety and performance requirements. All these aspects significantly contribute to why welded pipes have found their way into even the most demanding sectors, thereby affirming their strength and durability like no other pipes.

Comparative Strength of Seamless vs Welded Pipes

Factors Affecting the Strength of Seamless and Welded Pipes

• Material Composition

The chemical characteristics of the material used are the main factor in the strength of seamless and welded pipes. The use of higher-grade alloys and additives like chromium, molybdenum, and nickel leads to the development of better tensile strength, corrosion resistance, and overall durability. For instance, carbon steel pipes usually have a higher strength than standard stainless steel pipes.

• Manufacturing Process

Seamless pipes are made through extrusion or piercing processes that cut out the weld seams, although some minor variations in wall thickness might occur. On the contrary, welded pipes are highly dependent on the quality of the welding technique, which may be Electric Resistance Welding (ERW) or Submerged Arc Welding (SAW). Appropriate methods and qualified labor ensure that the welded region does not become a weak point. Research indicates that contemporary welding practices can obtain 80-90% of the uniform strength of seamless pipes.

• Heat Treatment

Heat treatment processes such as annealing, normalizing, or quenching have a direct effect on the uniformity of the material, and thus they can make it stronger, more ductile, and tougher. Both seamless and welded pipes can gain from whole heat treatment, but with welded pipes, it helps to lower the residual stresses around the weld seam.

• Wall Thickness

Higher wall thickness in seamless and welded pipes lead to greater pressure ratings and tolerance under very high stress. For example, pipes with a thickness of 10 mm can typically handle working pressures of 3000 psi, whereas those with thinner walls may burst under the same pressure.

• Inspection and Testing Standards

Pipes are guaranteed to be of good quality and reliable through rigorous tests like ultrasonic, radiographic, and hydrostatic. Seamless pipes undergo very strict testing to ensure uniform thickness, while welded pipes are inspected for any possible defects in the weld seam. Meeting the requirements of ASTM A53 or API 5L standards ensures that the pipes' performance will be consistent across all applications.

Pros and Cons of Seamless and Welded Pipes

Advantages of Seamless Pipes

• Higher Strength and Durability

The seamless pipes are produced without a weld joint, which is why they are much stronger and more durable than welded pipes, especially under high-pressure and high-temperature conditions.

• More Efficient Pressure Handling Capability

Seamless pipes can bear the pressure of internal fluid much better than pipes with seams, making them suitable for high-performance applications such as oil and gas pipelines or chemical processing systems.

• Uniform Structure

The seamless manufacturing process ensures the pipe's structure and composition are uniform. It also virtually eliminated any defects or inconsistencies that might affect the pipe's performance in critical installations.

• Wide Range of Applications

Seamless pipes are not only robust but also flexible and applicable in a variety of industries like oil and gas, energy, petrochemicals, construction, and shipbuilding. Their exceptional environmental tolerance leads to their popularity in these sectors.

• Longevity and Reliable Performance

Seamless pipes typically last longer than welded ones and require less maintenance. This means there would be less downtime and more reliable performance over a longer period.

Advantages of Welded Pipes

• Cost-Effectiveness

Most of the time, welded pipes are more cost-effective than seamless pipes. The production of welded pipes is less complicated, which makes them a money-saving option for many different industries.

• Versatility in Sizes

There is a huge variety of diameters and wall thicknesses for welded pipes. This wide range of sizes is available for use in applications that require pipes of specific dimensions.

• Ease of Production

Welded pipes are produced through a faster and more efficient process, thus large-scale production of these pipes is possible to supply high demand with only very slight delays.

• Sufficient Strength for Many Applications

If produced with proper quality control, welded pipes will have enough strength and durability for applications like water distribution, structural support, and low to medium-pressure systems.

• Customization and Availability

Welded pipes can be tailored to fit specific project needs without any difficulty. Also, they are always in good supply in the market because of their easier production methods which helps to cut down the lead time for procurement.

Tags: Are seamless pipes stronger than welded?